Groups Analysis: zscores

CASP1 - CASP9
(* results recalculated with new /updated structure comparison programs in 2019)

TS Analysis : Z-score based relative group performance

Models:

Ranking on the models designated as "1"
Ranking on best models

Groups:

All groups on 'all groups' targets
Server groups on 'all groups' + 'server only' targets

Formula and Domains:

GDT_TS

easy (TBM)
medium (TBM/FM)
hard (FM)

#	GR code	GR name	Domains Count	SUM Zscore (>-2.0)	Rank SUM Zscore (>-2.0)	AVG Zscore (>-2.0)	Rank AVG Zscore (>-2.0)	Rank SUM Zscore (>0.0)	Rank AVG Zscore (>0.0)
1	106	PRINCETON_TIGRESS	1	-2.0000	1	-2.0000	1	1	1
2	192	TsaiLab	2	-4.0000	2	-2.0000	1	1	1
3	490	Wiskers	3	-6.0000	3	-2.0000	1	1	1
4	404	ppfld	3	-6.0000	3	-2.0000	1	1	1
5	486	TAUbioinfounit	4	-8.0000	5	-2.0000	1	1	1
6	311	Nanoworld_Laboratory	4	-8.0000	5	-2.0000	1	1	1
7	186	Void_Crushers	5	-10.0000	7	-2.0000	1	1	1
8	342	Anthropic_Dreams	5	-10.0000	7	-2.0000	1	1	1
9	476	Foldit	5	-10.0000	7	-2.0000	1	1	1
10	040	GoScience	5	-10.0000	7	-2.0000	1	1	1
11	269	MBBS	5	-10.0000	7	-2.0000	1	1	1
12	361	Contenders	5	-10.0000	7	-2.0000	1	1	1
13	385	MICROGSIMU	5	-10.0000	7	-2.0000	1	1	1
14	281	WeFold-Wiskers	9	-18.0000	14	-2.0000	1	1	1
15	495	Mongolian_Team	10	-20.0000	15	-2.0000	1	1	1
16	428	Laufer	11	-22.0000	16	-2.0000	1	1	1
17	076	pkfc	11	-22.0000	16	-2.0000	1	1	1
18	386	MEAMT-group	11	-22.0000	16	-2.0000	1	1	1
19	077	OPIG	12	-24.0000	19	-2.0000	1	1	1
20	230	CASPITA3D	12	-24.0000	19	-2.0000	1	1	1
21	023	TAU_Course	13	-26.0000	21	-2.0000	1	1	1
22	128	wf-Baker-UNRES	14	-28.0000	22	-2.0000	1	1	1
23	465	Rosetta_at_Kingston	17	-34.0000	23	-2.0000	1	1	1
24	111	LNCCUnB	18	-36.0000	24	-2.0000	1	1	1
25	401	SSThread	20	-40.0000	25	-2.0000	1	1	1
26	260	wfZhng-Sk-BW	20	-40.0000	25	-2.0000	1	1	1
27	493	InnoUNRES	20	-40.0000	25	-2.0000	1	1	1
28	014	WeFold-Contenders	21	-42.0000	28	-2.0000	1	1	1
29	173	wfZhng-Ksr	22	-44.0000	29	-2.0000	1	1	1
30	433	WeFold-GoScience	24	-48.0000	30	-2.0000	1	1	1
31	336	wfKsrFdit-BW-Sk-BW	24	-48.0000	30	-2.0000	1	1	1
32	258	wf-Void_Crushers	24	-48.0000	30	-2.0000	1	1	1
33	024	dppred	24	-48.0000	30	-2.0000	1	1	1
34	120	wfKsrFdit-BW-Sk-McG	24	-48.0000	30	-2.0000	1	1	1
35	203	wf-AnthropicDreams	24	-48.0000	30	-2.0000	1	1	1
36	054	NEFILIM	32	-64.0000	36	-2.0000	1	1	1
37	110	MATRIX	32	-64.0000	36	-2.0000	1	1	1
38	171	MUFOLD-Server	44	-88.0000	38	-2.0000	1	1	1
39	206	PSF	44	-88.0000	38	-2.0000	1	1	1
40	065	Jones-UCL	45	-90.0000	40	-2.0000	1	1	1
41	466	RaptorX-FM	46	-92.0000	41	-2.0000	1	1	1
42	403	wfAll-Cheng	47	-94.0000	42	-2.0000	1	1	1
43	032	Legato	47	-94.0000	42	-2.0000	1	1	1
44	241	SHORTLE	50	-100.0000	44	-2.0000	1	1	1
45	073	SAM-T08-server	50	-100.0000	44	-2.0000	1	1	1
46	006	Sun_Tsinghua	51	-102.0000	46	-2.0000	1	1	1
47	162	McGuffin	53	-106.0000	47	-2.0000	1	1	1
48	301	Boniecki_pred	55	-110.0000	48	-2.0000	1	1	1
49	457	wfKeasar-PTIGRESS	56	-112.0000	49	-2.0000	1	1	1
50	362	BioShell	56	-112.0000	49	-2.0000	1	1	1
51	193	FFAS03	58	-116.0000	51	-2.0000	1	1	1
52	430	WY-C	60	-120.0000	52	-2.0000	1	1	1
53	340	Handl	61	-122.0000	53	-2.0000	1	1	1
54	317	keasar	63	-126.0000	54	-2.0000	1	1	1
55	197	wfMix-KFb	66	-132.0000	55	-2.0000	1	1	1
56	097	rluethy	66	-132.0000	55	-2.0000	1	1	1
57	445	Seder2	67	-134.0000	57	-2.0000	1	1	1
58	022	3D-Jigsaw-V5_1	67	-134.0000	57	-2.0000	1	1	1
59	153	wfAll-MD-RFLB	67	-134.0000	57	-2.0000	1	1	1
60	460	Victoria	68	-136.0000	60	-2.0000	1	1	1
61	116	2PG	68	-136.0000	60	-2.0000	1	1	1
62	483	LmtdSeder	68	-136.0000	60	-2.0000	1	1	1
63	437	ALAdeGAP	71	-142.0000	63	-2.0000	1	1	1
64	080	MeilerLab	71	-142.0000	63	-2.0000	1	1	1
65	479	RBO_Aleph	72	-144.0000	65	-2.0000	1	1	1
66	482	wfMix-KPa	72	-144.0000	65	-2.0000	1	1	1
67	056	wfMix-KPb	72	-144.0000	65	-2.0000	1	1	1
68	118	wfMix-KFa	72	-144.0000	65	-2.0000	1	1	1
69	434	QA-RecombineIt_H2	72	-144.0000	65	-2.0000	1	1	1
70	322	Bilab	72	-144.0000	65	-2.0000	1	1	1
71	417	chuo-fams	72	-144.0000	65	-2.0000	1	1	1
72	364	QA-RecombineIt_WFH	72	-144.0000	65	-2.0000	1	1	1
73	156	Atome2_CBS	73	-146.0000	73	-2.0000	1	1	1
74	235	FLOUDAS_A3	73	-146.0000	73	-2.0000	1	1	1
75	210	BioSerf	73	-146.0000	73	-2.0000	1	1	1
76	310	MUFOLD-R	73	-146.0000	73	-2.0000	1	1	1
77	368	Seder1	73	-146.0000	73	-2.0000	1	1	1
78	034	wfHHPred-PTIGRESS	73	-146.0000	73	-2.0000	1	1	1
79	438	QA-RecombineIt_H	74	-148.0000	79	-2.0000	1	1	1
80	300	PhyreX	75	-150.0000	80	-2.0000	1	1	1
81	391	Chicken_George	75	-150.0000	80	-2.0000	1	1	1
82	237	chuo-fams-server	75	-150.0000	80	-2.0000	1	1	1
83	263	STRINGS	76	-152.0000	83	-2.0000	1	1	1
84	145	BioShell-server	76	-152.0000	83	-2.0000	1	1	1
85	333	Kiharalab	76	-152.0000	83	-2.0000	1	1	1
86	492	slbio	77	-154.0000	86	-2.0000	1	1	1
87	026	Bates_BMM	77	-154.0000	86	-2.0000	1	1	1
88	349	Distill	77	-154.0000	86	-2.0000	1	1	1
89	282	PML	77	-154.0000	86	-2.0000	1	1	1
90	448	FLOUDAS_SERVER	77	-154.0000	86	-2.0000	1	1	1
91	436	Alpha-Gelly-Server	78	-156.0000	91	-2.0000	1	1	1
92	268	MULTICOM-REFINE	78	-156.0000	91	-2.0000	1	1	1
93	410	Pcons-net	78	-156.0000	91	-2.0000	1	1	1
94	276	FLOUDAS_A4	78	-156.0000	91	-2.0000	1	1	1
95	277	Zhang-Server	78	-156.0000	91	-2.0000	1	1	1
96	133	IntFOLD3	78	-156.0000	91	-2.0000	1	1	1
97	144	Mufold	78	-156.0000	91	-2.0000	1	1	1
98	155	Cornell-Gdansk	78	-156.0000	91	-2.0000	1	1	1
99	160	ZHOU-SPARKS-X	78	-156.0000	91	-2.0000	1	1	1
100	326	FLOUDAS_A2	78	-156.0000	91	-2.0000	1	1	1
101	169	LEE	78	-156.0000	91	-2.0000	1	1	1
102	425	Seok-refine	78	-156.0000	91	-2.0000	1	1	1
103	184	BAKER-ROSETTASERVER	78	-156.0000	91	-2.0000	1	1	1
104	442	wfCPUNK	78	-156.0000	91	-2.0000	1	1	1
105	296	Seok	78	-156.0000	91	-2.0000	1	1	1
106	439	Pareto	78	-156.0000	91	-2.0000	1	1	1
107	204	Zhang	78	-156.0000	91	-2.0000	1	1	1
108	290	MULTICOM	78	-156.0000	91	-2.0000	1	1	1
109	212	FFAS-3D	78	-156.0000	91	-2.0000	1	1	1
110	216	myprotein-me	78	-156.0000	91	-2.0000	1	1	1
111	228	BhageerathH	78	-156.0000	91	-2.0000	1	1	1
112	251	TASSER-VMT	78	-156.0000	91	-2.0000	1	1	1
113	279	HHPredX	78	-156.0000	91	-2.0000	1	1	1
114	381	FALCON_MANUAL	78	-156.0000	91	-2.0000	1	1	1
115	038	nns	78	-156.0000	91	-2.0000	1	1	1
116	041	MULTICOM-NOVEL	78	-156.0000	91	-2.0000	1	1	1
117	042	TASSER	78	-156.0000	91	-2.0000	1	1	1
118	044	LEER	78	-156.0000	91	-2.0000	1	1	1
119	049	DELCLAB	78	-156.0000	91	-2.0000	1	1	1
120	050	RaptorX	78	-156.0000	91	-2.0000	1	1	1
121	414	FALCON_MANUAL_X	78	-156.0000	91	-2.0000	1	1	1
122	011	Seok-server	78	-156.0000	91	-2.0000	1	1	1
123	063	KIAS-GDANSK	78	-156.0000	91	-2.0000	1	1	1
124	064	BAKER	78	-156.0000	91	-2.0000	1	1	1
125	358	Skwark	78	-156.0000	91	-2.0000	1	1	1
126	067	CNIO	78	-156.0000	91	-2.0000	1	1	1
127	357	STAP	78	-156.0000	91	-2.0000	1	1	1
128	347	Wallner	78	-156.0000	91	-2.0000	1	1	1
129	346	HHPredA	78	-156.0000	91	-2.0000	1	1	1
130	345	FUSION	78	-156.0000	91	-2.0000	1	1	1
131	338	ProQ2	78	-156.0000	91	-2.0000	1	1	1
132	008	MULTICOM-CONSTRUCT	78	-156.0000	91	-2.0000	1	1	1
133	420	MULTICOM-CLUSTER	78	-156.0000	91	-2.0000	1	1	1
134	335	FALCON_TOPO	78	-156.0000	91	-2.0000	1	1	1
135	117	raghavagps-tsppred	78	-156.0000	91	-2.0000	1	1	1
136	499	QUARK	78	-156.0000	91	-2.0000	1	1	1
137	454	eThread	78	-156.0000	91	-2.0000	1	1	1
138	452	FALCON_EnvFold	78	-156.0000	91	-2.0000	1	1	1
139	132	ProQ2-refine	78	-156.0000	91	-2.0000	1	1	1

The cummulative z-scores in this table are calculated according to the following procedure (example for the "first" models):
1. Calculate z-scores from the raw scores for all "first" models (corresponding values from the main result table);
2. Remove outliers - models with zscores below the tolerance threshold (set to -2.0);
3. Recalculate z-scores on the reduced dataset;
4. Assign z-scores below the penalty threshold (either -2.0 or 0.0) to the value of this threshold.

Protein Structure Prediction Center
Sponsored by the US National Institute of General Medical Sciences (NIH/NIGMS)
Please address any questions or queries to:
© 2007-2026, University of California, Davis