13th Community Wide Experiment on the
Critical Assessment of Techniques for Protein Structure Prediction
Improvements in models over copying from templates. Target: T0999-D4
Results Home Table Browser Estimate of Model Accuracy Results RR Assessment Results
  Tables   GDT Plots   Local Accuracy   Position-specific alignment   Templates   Help
 
Selected templates/models  |  Models strip charts  |  Templates strip charts
Models / 25 Best templates vs targets CA-CA distances
View: Templates Model Difference     
Green line: distance between the aligned CA atoms in a template and the experimental structure in the LGA sequence-independent superposition under the 5A distance cutoff (see LGA description).
Blue line: distance between the corresponding CA atoms in a model and the experimental structure in the LGA sequence-independent superposition under the 5A distance cutoff.
Red line = (blue line) - (green thick line): difference between the corresponding Model-Target and Template-Target CA-CA distances (see above). Negative values show regions where a model has better fit to the target than the template, i.e. areas of potential improvement over the template.
Thin lines: other templates
The plot above is generated applying the moving average method with window of 3 positions.
Color gamma <-5 (-5; -2) (-2; -0.5) (-0.5; 0.5) (0.5; 2) (2; 5) >5 or N/A
Differences percentage0.0%2.0%11.5%81.6%4.9%0.0%0.0%
Radio buttons select the template for which difference is calculated

Checkboxes select template for visualization in the graph

* the best template selected by assessors

Top 25 Templates
  #TemplatesLGA_SRMSD
1 5swuB 96.597 0.87
2 5swvC 95.152 1.05
3 4cnpB 84.608 1.73
4 4clmB 84.521 1.73
5 3m7wA 84.496 1.73
6 1qfeA 84.493 1.71
7 2yr1B 84.363 1.7
8 1l9wD 84.14 1.74
9 3nntB 84.126 1.79
10 3lb0A 84.029 1.79
11 3js3C 83.991 1.8
12 4uioA 83.889 1.76
13 4guiA 83.792 1.77
14 4iuoA 83.776 1.8
15 4gujA 83.745 1.76
16 3s42A 83.736 1.81
17 4guhA 83.678 1.8
18 4gfsA 83.506 1.8
19 3oexD 83.341 1.76
20 4cnnB 83.06 1.73
21 4h3dB 82.803 1.81
22 3o1nA 82.747 1.84
23 4cnoD 82.503 1.76
24 3l2iA 82.028 1.8
25 4gugB 81.856 1.84
Models
 #NameLGA_SRMSDGDT_TS 
1 T0999TS377_4-D4 98.427 0.81 95.90
2 T0999TS322_2-D4 98.33 0.86 95.49
3 T0999TS377_2-D4 98.26 0.81 95.29
4 T0999TS377_1-D4 97.714 0.90 95.18
5 T0999TS322_1-D4 98.042 0.87 94.98
6 T0999TS214_1-D4 98.028 0.87 94.88
7 T0999TS377_3-D4 97.953 0.85 94.78
8 T0999TS214_2-D4 97.739 0.83 94.67
9 T0999TS377_5-D4 96.351 0.99 93.95
10 T0999TS390_3-D4 97.192 0.97 93.95
11 T0999TS390_4-D4 97.117 1.04 93.85
12 T0999TS390_2-D4 97.205 1.02 93.85
13 T0999TS390_1-D4 97.169 1.02 93.75
14 T0999TS086_5-D4 97.162 0.96 93.65
15 T0999TS214_4-D4 97.167 1.05 93.55
16 T0999TS324_1-D4 96.513 0.96 93.34
17 T0999TS160_1-D4 96.978 0.99 93.34
18 T0999TS446_5-D4 96.513 0.96 93.34
19 T0999TS344_2-D4 96.513 0.96 93.34
20 T0999TS221_1-D4 96.513 0.96 93.34
21 T0999TS344_4-D4 96.513 0.96 93.34
22 T0999TS044_2-D4 96.978 0.99 93.34
23 T0999TS243_5-D4 95.377 0.87 93.24
24 T0999TS192_2-D4 96.058 0.85 93.14
25 T0999TS241_2-D4 96.058 0.85 93.14
26 T0999TS071_5-D4 96.058 0.85 93.14
27 T0999TS192_5-D4 96.058 0.85 93.14
28 T0999TS368_3-D4 96.058 0.85 93.14
29 T0999TS055_5-D4 96.058 0.85 93.14
30 T0999TS309_1-D4 96.058 0.85 93.14
31 T0999TS457_4-D4 96.058 0.85 93.14
32 T0999TS164_5-D4 96.678 1.01 93.03
33 T0999TS164_2-D4 96.678 1.01 93.03
34 T0999TS214_3-D4 96.953 1.04 92.93
35 T0999TS418_5-D4 95.796 0.80 92.93
36 T0999TS406_2-D4 95.796 0.80 92.93
37 T0999TS368_1-D4 95.796 0.80 92.93
38 T0999TS457_3-D4 95.796 0.80 92.93
39 T0999TS055_4-D4 95.796 0.80 92.93
40 T0999TS309_4-D4 95.796 0.80 92.93
41 T0999TS426_5-D4 95.796 0.80 92.93
42 T0999TS241_3-D4 95.796 0.80 92.93
43 T0999TS344_3-D4 95.796 0.80 92.93
44 T0999TS224_4-D4 95.796 0.80 92.83
45 T0999TS086_4-D4 97.259 0.98 92.72
46 T0999TS274_3-D4 95.292 0.89 92.72
47 T0999TS471_1-D4 96.2 0.98 92.62
48 T0999TS322_3-D4 95.355 0.85 92.42
49 T0999TS055_2-D4 95.13 0.87 92.42
50 T0999TS426_3-D4 95.13 0.87 92.42
51 T0999TS344_5-D4 95.13 0.87 92.42
52 T0999TS192_1-D4 95.13 0.87 92.42
53 T0999TS274_1-D4 95.562 0.85 92.42
54 T0999TS368_2-D4 95.13 0.87 92.42
55 T0999TS241_5-D4 95.13 0.87 92.42
56 T0999TS274_2-D4 95.456 0.94 92.32
57 T0999TS274_4-D4 95.512 0.92 92.32
58 T0999TS418_2-D4 96.732 1.08 92.21
59 T0999TS446_4-D4 96.732 1.08 92.21
60 T0999TS426_2-D4 96.029 1.06 92.21
61 T0999TS261_2-D4 96.732 1.08 92.21
62 T0999TS426_4-D4 95.86 1.06 92.11
63 T0999TS197_4-D4 95.105 0.91 92.11
64 T0999TS004_1-D4 96.466 1.09 92.11
65 T0999TS390_5-D4 95.963 1.10 92.11
66 T0999TS274_5-D4 95.424 0.95 92.11
67 T0999TS457_1-D4 95.391 0.93 92.01
68 T0999TS446_2-D4 95.391 0.93 92.01
69 T0999TS426_1-D4 95.391 0.93 92.01
70 T0999TS244_4-D4 95.391 0.93 92.01
71 T0999TS406_1-D4 95.391 0.93 92.01
72 T0999TS241_1-D4 95.391 0.93 92.01
73 T0999TS344_1-D4 95.391 0.93 92.01
74 T0999TS055_1-D4 95.391 0.93 92.01
75 T0999TS368_4-D4 95.391 0.93 92.01
76 T0999TS086_1-D4 96.356 1.02 91.91
77 T0999TS071_1-D4 95.988 1.11 91.91
78 T0999TS261_1-D4 95.988 1.11 91.91
79 T0999TS244_2-D4 95.988 1.11 91.91
80 T0999TS457_2-D4 96.436 1.09 91.91
81 T0999TS004_2-D4 96.436 1.09 91.91
82 T0999TS224_5-D4 95.391 0.93 91.91
83 T0999TS446_3-D4 96.004 1.09 91.80
84 T0999TS145_1-D4 96.004 1.09 91.80
85 T0999TS324_2-D4 95.391 1.05 91.80
86 T0999TS196_2-D4 95.422 1.05 91.80
87 T0999TS354_4-D4 96.225 1.12 91.80
88 T0999TS135_1-D4 95.391 1.05 91.80
89 T0999TS086_3-D4 96.365 1.05 91.60
90 T0999TS222_2-D4 95.74 1.08 91.50
91 T0999TS222_4-D4 95.391 1.08 91.50
92 T0999TS156_1-D4 95.087 1.07 91.29
93 T0999TS460_2-D4 94.758 1.05 91.29
94 T0999TS460_1-D4 94.758 1.05 91.29
95 T0999TS460_3-D4 94.886 1.05 91.29
96 T0999TS460_5-D4 94.821 1.05 91.19
97 T0999TS354_1-D4 95.321 1.07 91.19
98 T0999TS354_5-D4 95.323 1.03 91.19
99 T0999TS460_4-D4 94.704 0.99 91.19
100 T0999TS197_3-D4 95.244 1.07 91.19
101 T0999TS089_1-D4 95.966 1.03 91.19
102 T0999TS149_1-D4 96.132 1.12 91.09
103 T0999TS279_1-D4 96.132 1.12 91.09
104 T0999TS244_3-D4 96.132 1.12 91.09
105 T0999TS071_2-D4 96.132 1.12 91.09
106 T0999TS214_5-D4 96.107 1.16 91.09
107 T0999TS163_1-D4 95.361 1.00 90.98
108 T0999TS160_5-D4 96.049 1.08 90.88
109 T0999TS222_1-D4 95.38 1.10 90.78
110 T0999TS163_2-D4 95.42 1.01 90.78
111 T0999TS243_1-D4 94.773 1.02 90.68
112 T0999TS156_3-D4 94.841 1.13 90.68
113 T0999TS164_1-D4 96.401 1.05 90.68
114 T0999TS055_3-D4 94.841 1.13 90.68
115 T0999TS135_2-D4 94.841 1.13 90.68
116 T0999TS196_1-D4 94.841 1.13 90.68
117 T0999TS156_4-D4 95.317 1.07 90.57
118 T0999TS197_2-D4 95.229 1.10 90.57
119 T0999TS047_3-D4 95.138 1.04 90.57
120 T0999TS164_4-D4 96.141 1.04 90.57
121 T0999TS446_1-D4 95.317 1.07 90.57
122 T0999TS222_5-D4 95.05 1.12 90.57
123 T0999TS163_4-D4 95.231 1.01 90.47
124 T0999TS397_3-D4 94.611 1.08 90.37
125 T0999TS047_2-D4 95.231 1.05 90.37
126 T0999TS163_5-D4 95.12 1.06 90.37
127 T0999TS197_1-D4 94.435 1.11 90.37
128 T0999TS047_1-D4 95.264 1.04 90.37
129 T0999TS197_5-D4 95.087 1.18 90.27
130 T0999TS086_2-D4 95.727 1.13 90.27
131 T0999TS163_3-D4 95.141 1.03 90.27
132 T0999TS366_3-D4 94.663 1.15 90.27
133 T0999TS047_4-D4 95.228 1.05 90.27
134 T0999TS488_3-D4 95.752 1.11 90.16
135 T0999TS047_5-D4 95.303 1.07 90.16
136 T0999TS441_2-D4 95.041 1.14 90.06
137 T0999TS135_5-D4 94.234 1.14 89.86
138 T0999TS488_5-D4 95.573 1.15 89.86
139 T0999TS441_1-D4 94.234 1.14 89.86
140 T0999TS337_1-D4 94.841 1.07 89.86
141 T0999TS441_3-D4 94.546 1.10 89.75
142 T0999TS337_2-D4 95.107 1.10 89.75
143 T0999TS337_3-D4 95.005 1.10 89.75
144 T0999TS243_4-D4 93.355 1.01 89.65
145 T0999TS441_4-D4 94.827 1.10 89.65
146 T0999TS337_4-D4 94.42 1.10 89.55
147 T0999TS023_4-D4 93.234 1.04 89.55
148 T0999TS222_3-D4 95.157 1.20 89.45
149 T0999TS044_1-D4 93.908 1.21 89.34
150 T0999TS441_5-D4 93.908 1.21 89.34
151 T0999TS329_5-D4 95.075 1.15 89.34
152 T0999TS089_2-D4 94.194 1.16 89.34
153 T0999TS156_5-D4 94.442 1.16 89.04
154 T0999TS354_3-D4 94.065 1.18 89.04
155 T0999TS241_4-D4 94.442 1.16 89.04
156 T0999TS337_5-D4 93.879 1.18 88.93
157 T0999TS135_4-D4 93.205 1.12 88.63
158 T0999TS023_1-D4 92.423 0.97 88.63
159 T0999TS196_3-D4 93.205 1.12 88.53
160 T0999TS243_3-D4 93.175 1.12 88.53
161 T0999TS023_5-D4 93.417 1.10 88.32
162 T0999TS058_4-D4 92.677 1.11 88.01
163 T0999TS068_5-D4 94.144 1.25 88.01
164 T0999TS068_1-D4 94.032 1.30 87.81
165 T0999TS224_1-D4 93.365 1.21 87.70
166 T0999TS068_4-D4 93.937 1.30 87.60
167 T0999TS089_3-D4 89.923 1.06 87.60
168 T0999TS068_3-D4 93.976 1.29 87.50
169 T0999TS023_2-D4 92.636 1.08 87.40
170 T0999TS068_2-D4 93.506 1.25 87.40
171 T0999TS470_4-D4 92.355 1.34 86.99
172 T0999TS366_4-D4 91.537 1.17 86.89
173 T0999TS322_4-D4 91.399 1.06 86.68
174 T0999TS470_3-D4 91.868 1.31 86.47
175 T0999TS089_5-D4 91.685 1.12 86.37
176 T0999TS135_3-D4 92.157 1.34 86.27
177 T0999TS196_5-D4 92.188 1.34 86.27
178 T0999TS470_5-D4 92.157 1.34 86.27
179 T0999TS224_3-D4 93.072 1.25 86.17
180 T0999TS243_2-D4 90.901 1.11 85.86
181 T0999TS071_3-D4 93.417 1.30 85.86
182 T0999TS116_5-D4 93.417 1.30 85.86
183 T0999TS309_5-D4 93.417 1.30 85.86
184 T0999TS023_3-D4 90.737 1.25 85.76
185 T0999TS112_2-D4 91.712 1.25 85.55
186 T0999TS457_5-D4 91.843 1.25 85.45
187 T0999TS110_1-D4 91.843 1.25 85.45
188 T0999TS156_2-D4 92.869 1.39 85.25
189 T0999TS089_4-D4 90.734 1.23 85.14
190 T0999TS397_1-D4 89.981 1.27 84.73
191 T0999TS354_2-D4 91.255 1.32 84.63
192 T0999TS366_1-D4 91.034 1.38 84.53
193 T0999TS110_4-D4 87.572 1.22 83.09
194 T0999TS261_5-D4 89.382 1.46 82.89
195 T0999TS112_4-D4 90.274 1.37 82.89
196 T0999TS071_4-D4 89.382 1.46 82.89
197 T0999TS406_4-D4 89.382 1.46 82.89
198 T0999TS246_4-D4 89.91 1.52 82.07
199 T0999TS246_3-D4 89.91 1.52 82.07
200 T0999TS112_1-D4 89.574 1.29 81.86
201 T0999TS145_5-D4 88.81 1.52 81.76
202 T0999TS110_5-D4 88.686 1.46 81.76
203 T0999TS112_3-D4 89.882 1.45 81.35
204 T0999TS110_3-D4 87.281 1.37 80.84
205 T0999TS110_2-D4 85.929 1.43 80.22
206 T0999TS145_4-D4 87.015 1.58 80.22
207 T0999TS418_1-D4 87.345 1.61 79.71
208 T0999TS261_4-D4 87.345 1.61 79.71
209 T0999TS244_1-D4 87.345 1.61 79.71
210 T0999TS309_2-D4 87.345 1.61 79.71
211 T0999TS043_2-D4 88.44 1.62 79.51
212 T0999TS112_5-D4 88.156 1.44 79.41
213 T0999TS043_3-D4 88.302 1.58 79.10
214 T0999TS043_4-D4 87.302 1.61 78.79
215 T0999TS043_1-D4 87.5 1.64 78.07
216 T0999TS043_5-D4 87.66 1.63 78.07
217 T0999TS058_3-D4 82.122 1.51 76.84
218 T0999TS124_2-D4 86.474 1.59 76.43
219 T0999TS366_2-D4 84.043 1.57 75.82
220 T0999TS145_3-D4 83.583 1.77 75.10
221 T0999TS145_2-D4 83.583 1.77 75.10
222 T0999TS044_4-D4 83.583 1.77 75.10
223 T0999TS124_1-D4 84.759 1.68 74.59
224 T0999TS261_3-D4 83.294 1.76 74.08
225 T0999TS124_5-D4 84.302 1.74 73.67
226 T0999TS192_4-D4 82.05 1.53 73.05
227 T0999TS058_1-D4 82.05 1.53 73.05
228 T0999TS124_4-D4 83.923 1.80 72.23
229 T0999TS124_3-D4 82.949 1.79 71.62
230 T0999TS224_2-D4 79.285 1.93 71.11
231 T0999TS498_4-D4 82.129 1.80 70.70
232 T0999TS498_2-D4 79.24 1.80 69.88
233 T0999TS498_3-D4 82.064 1.80 69.88
234 T0999TS498_5-D4 80.823 1.88 69.67
235 T0999TS498_1-D4 79.16 1.85 69.36
236 T0999TS196_4-D4 79.16 1.85 69.36
237 T0999TS149_2-D4 72.459 1.87 69.26
238 T0999TS279_2-D4 72.459 1.87 69.26
239 T0999TS366_5-D4 76.983 1.83 67.52
240 T0999TS406_5-D4 75.24 1.91 67.42
241 T0999TS116_3-D4 75.24 1.91 67.42
242 T0999TS116_4-D4 72.598 1.96 67.21
243 T0999TS117_1-D4 72.37 2.12 66.29
244 T0999TS432_1-D4 76.318 1.91 65.98
245 T0999TS329_3-D4 70.441 1.99 65.98
246 T0999TS329_4-D4 70.441 1.99 65.98
247 T0999TS329_2-D4 70.441 1.99 65.98
248 T0999TS329_1-D4 70.441 1.99 65.98
249 T0999TS116_1-D4 73.408 2.00 65.68
250 T0999TS309_3-D4 73.408 2.00 65.68
251 T0999TS418_3-D4 73.408 2.00 65.68
252 T0999TS244_5-D4 73.408 2.00 65.68
253 T0999TS116_2-D4 73.408 2.00 65.68
254 T0999TS470_1-D4 67.802 1.94 65.47
255 T0999TS432_2-D4 68.746 1.91 65.27
256 T0999TS160_4-D4 67.53 1.92 65.16
257 T0999TS164_3-D4 66.761 2.01 65.06
258 T0999TS058_2-D4 71.445 1.92 64.86
259 T0999TS470_2-D4 66.419 1.95 63.83
260 T0999TS058_5-D4 68.068 1.90 63.32
261 T0999TS397_2-D4 58.028 2.03 60.55
262 T0999TS246_1-D4 59.874 2.10 60.45
263 T0999TS246_2-D4 59.874 2.10 60.45
264 T0999TS397_4-D4 54.152 1.93 59.84
265 T0999TS322_5-D4 59.492 2.12 59.84
266 T0999TS041_1-D4 55.454 2.05 57.79
267 T0999TS246_5-D4 52.954 2.04 52.97
268 T0999TS288_3-D4 41.212 2.43 46.41
269 T0999TS288_1-D4 40.978 2.63 46.00
270 T0999TS288_4-D4 37.313 2.46 41.60
271 T0999TS381_1-D4 37.327 2.36 39.04
272 T0999TS381_2-D4 37.327 2.36 39.04
273 T0999TS288_5-D4 34.523 2.50 36.99
274 T0999TS288_2-D4 31.214 2.70 36.48
275 T0999TS312_5-D4 36.065 2.45 35.66
276 T0999TS365_4-D4 38.732 1.72 34.84
277 T0999TS365_5-D4 38.46 1.62 34.53
278 T0999TS365_1-D4 37.975 1.75 34.02
279 T0999TS365_2-D4 37.637 1.67 33.81
280 T0999TS365_3-D4 38.391 1.73 33.50
281 T0999TS348_1-D4 26.34 2.76 29.30
282 T0999TS348_3-D4 27.196 2.65 29.20
283 T0999TS348_2-D4 26.72 2.83 28.69
284 T0999TS348_4-D4 23.893 2.78 28.18
285 T0999TS152_3-D4 18.282 2.68 19.67
286 T0999TS044_5-D4 18.282 2.68 19.67
287 T0999TS497_2-D4 14.036 2.70 18.24
288 T0999TS497_1-D4 16.007 2.58 18.24
289 T0999TS497_5-D4 13.682 2.92 15.98
290 T0999TS497_4-D4 7.937 2.77 15.06
291 T0999TS152_4-D4 14.477 2.87 14.34
292 T0999TS152_1-D4 11.666 2.78 13.93
293 T0999TS497_3-D4 12.974 2.79 13.42
294 T0999TS152_5-D4 13.315 2.59 12.91
295 T0999TS149_3-D4 12.584 2.51 12.91
296 T0999TS279_3-D4 12.584 2.51 12.91
297 T0999TS152_2-D4 10.345 2.72 12.71
298 T0999TS348_5-D4 10.188 2.68 12.71
299 T0999TS418_4-D4 15.044 2.46 12.60
300 T0999TS279_4-D4 15.044 2.46 12.60
301 T0999TS149_4-D4 15.044 2.46 12.60
302 T0999TS149_5-D4 13.561 2.38 11.37
303 T0999TS312_1-D4 11.162 2.52 11.37
304 T0999TS279_5-D4 13.561 2.38 11.37
305 T0999TS312_2-D4 12.397 2.69 11.37
306 T0999TS406_3-D4 13.561 2.38 11.37
307 T0999TS085_5-D4 11.557 2.77 11.17
308 T0999TS472_2-D4 17.467 2.53 11.17
309 T0999TS472_4-D4 19.587 2.65 11.07
310 T0999TS472_3-D4 17.67 2.64 10.96
311 T0999TS472_5-D4 16.622 2.76 10.96
312 T0999TS378_4-D4 9.292 2.64 10.76
313 T0999TS085_4-D4 14.385 2.77 10.76
314 T0999TS472_1-D4 18.141 2.65 10.76
315 T0999TS335_1-D4 11.028 2.55 10.55
316 T0999TS335_2-D4 11.028 2.55 10.55
317 T0999TS335_3-D4 11.028 2.55 10.55
318 T0999TS335_4-D4 11.028 2.55 10.55
319 T0999TS378_1-D4 11.028 2.55 10.55
320 T0999TS335_5-D4 11.028 2.55 10.55
321 T0999TS004_4-D4 10.351 2.18 10.35
322 T0999TS378_3-D4 11.026 2.25 9.94
323 T0999TS378_5-D4 10.904 2.56 9.43
324 T0999TS007_2-D4 20.38 2.55 8.81
325 T0999TS085_3-D4 12.781 2.62 8.61
326 T0999TS007_3-D4 8.346 2.60 8.61
327 T0999TS007_4-D4 12.405 2.41 7.89
328 T0999TS378_2-D4 7.501 2.57 7.79
329 T0999TS007_1-D4 10.93 2.56 7.58
330 T0999TS085_2-D4 10.18 2.91 7.48
331 T0999TS085_1-D4 11.902 2.61 7.07
332 T0999TS488_1-D4 6.372 2.27 5.74
333 T0999TS007_5-D4 8.27 2.56 5.43
334 T0999TS160_2-D4 5.492 2.01 5.22
335 T0999TS488_2-D4 5.829 2.00 4.92
336 T0999TS041_4-D4 6.324 1.76 4.92
337 T0999TS432_3-D4 5.857 1.86 4.82
338 T0999TS160_3-D4 5.265 2.32 4.82
339 T0999TS044_3-D4 5.857 1.86 4.82
340 T0999TS041_2-D4 5.626 1.77 4.82
341 T0999TS488_4-D4 5.964 2.52 4.82
342 T0999TS041_3-D4 5.808 2.26 4.71
343 T0999TS041_5-D4 5.077 1.99 4.61
344 T0999TS312_4-D4 4.114 2.40 3.79
345 T0999TS312_3-D4 4.44 2.24 3.79
Difference model - template
# Templates
1 5swuB
2 5swvC
3 4cnpB
4 4clmB
5 3m7wA
6 1qfeA
7 2yr1B
8 1l9wD
9 3nntB
10 3lb0A
11 3js3C
12 4uioA
13 4guiA
14 4iuoA
15 4gujA
16 3s42A
17 4guhA
18 4gfsA
19 3oexD
20 4cnnB
21 4h3dB
22 3o1nA
23 4cnoD
24 3l2iA
25 4gugB
Protein Structure Prediction Center
Sponsored by the US National Institute of General Medical Sciences (NIH/NIGMS)
Please address any questions or queries to:
© 2007-2018, University of California, Davis