9th Community Wide Experiment on the
Critical Assessment of Techniques for Protein Structure Prediction
Menu
Group performance based on MODEL 1 analysis
    • All groups on server/human targets
    • Server groups on server/human + server only targets
    • TBM
    • TBM/FM
    • FM
# GR # GR name Domains Count SUM Z-score (GDT_TS) AVG Z-score (GDT_TS) AVG GDT_TS SUM Z-score (AL0P) AVG AL0P AVG GDT_HA AVG CA(i)-CA(i+1) AVG Mammoth (Z-Score) AVG Dali (Z-Score) AVG response time, min
1. 386 Mufold 77 78.012 1.013 56.561 0.995 52.439 40.896 3.754 13.206 10.690 0.000
2. 096 Zhang 78 77.924 0.999 56.133 0.934 51.617 40.194 3.779 13.277 10.399 0.000
3. 470 elofsson 78 76.778 0.984 55.532 0.900 49.808 39.693 3.783 13.210 10.023 0.000
4. 490 MULTICOM 78 73.444 0.942 55.059 0.836 48.869 39.407 3.754 12.970 10.401 0.000
5. 016 Seok-meta 77 72.951 0.947 55.274 0.842 49.545 39.825 3.755 12.823 10.178 0.000
6. 113 FAMSSEC 78 72.891 0.934 54.511 0.867 47.586 38.288 3.894 13.016 10.235 0.000
7. 407 United3D 78 71.204 0.913 54.999 0.945 50.971 39.263 3.776 13.069 10.418 0.000
8. 399 Chicken_George 78 71.016 0.910 54.263 0.917 48.206 38.555 3.772 12.887 10.542 0.000
9. 033 RecombineIt 77 70.983 0.922 55.513 0.864 49.468 39.356 3.763 13.348 10.314 0.000
10. 094 McGuffin 78 70.377 0.902 55.260 0.881 50.261 39.606 3.768 13.042 10.383 0.000
11. 037 fams-ace3 78 69.290 0.888 54.442 0.862 48.470 38.295 3.873 13.142 9.964 0.000
12. 065 prmls 78 68.721 0.881 54.105 0.803 48.045 38.596 3.763 12.721 9.977 0.000
13. 380 QUARK 78 66.825 0.857 54.016 0.768 48.726 38.320 3.777 12.898 9.697 3515.639
14. 429 fams-multi 78 66.249 0.849 53.908 0.830 48.674 38.246 3.842 12.702 10.238 0.000
15. 361 LEEcon 76 65.257 0.859 55.265 0.831 50.069 39.505 3.753 12.684 10.489 0.000
16. 428 Zhang-Server 78 65.097 0.835 54.230 0.803 49.713 38.566 3.780 12.934 9.860 3500.269
17. 110 Sternberg 78 64.914 0.832 53.725 0.860 48.614 38.337 3.790 12.719 10.182 0.000
18. 418 Zhang_Ab_Initio 78 62.491 0.801 52.949 0.685 46.672 37.962 3.790 12.325 9.885 0.000
19. 402 TASSER 78 61.380 0.787 53.307 0.776 48.066 37.107 3.798 12.488 9.577 0.000
20. 088 Splicer 78 60.626 0.777 52.032 0.725 44.773 36.608 3.878 12.566 9.897 0.000
21. 077 RaptorX-MSA 78 59.682 0.765 52.979 0.722 46.208 37.451 3.766 12.776 10.047 3663.293
22. 240 TMD3D 74 59.672 0.806 50.790 0.714 42.771 35.963 3.783 11.468 8.782 0.000
23. 286 RaptorX 78 59.576 0.764 52.924 0.787 47.431 37.166 3.772 12.808 9.755 3631.353
24. 104 Jones-UCL 78 59.067 0.757 53.068 0.743 46.275 38.098 3.768 12.397 10.069 0.000
25. 276 RaptorX-Boost 78 57.651 0.739 52.699 0.739 46.548 36.841 3.778 12.806 9.663 3631.332
26. 299 bujnicki-kolinski 77 56.798 0.738 52.333 0.700 45.752 36.501 3.764 12.509 9.448 0.000
27. 147 GeneSilico 78 55.713 0.714 51.934 0.675 44.044 36.116 3.771 12.339 9.167 0.000
28. 400 LTB 78 55.037 0.706 51.857 0.645 44.031 35.913 3.716 12.409 9.241 0.000
29. 172 BAKER 78 54.686 0.701 51.772 0.669 44.607 36.651 3.803 12.011 9.036 0.000
30. 192 BIO_ICM 71 53.874 0.759 53.053 0.717 47.987 37.592 3.750 12.712 10.046 0.000
31. 295 KnowMIN 78 53.625 0.688 49.337 0.646 40.166 35.182 3.800 11.514 8.535 0.000
32. 114 LEE 78 53.182 0.682 50.507 0.660 42.173 36.173 3.779 11.686 9.610 0.000
33. 365 SHORTLE 73 52.673 0.722 52.631 0.717 47.346 37.262 3.774 13.083 9.775 0.000
34. 242 Seok 77 51.213 0.665 51.773 0.635 44.631 36.675 3.761 12.086 9.990 0.000
35. 297 SWA_TEST 78 50.837 0.652 50.146 0.609 41.992 35.451 3.795 11.976 9.319 0.000
36. 321 BAKER-ROSETTASERVER 78 50.221 0.644 50.037 0.672 42.838 35.758 3.799 11.591 8.953 3628.810
37. 408 keasar 78 49.792 0.638 50.394 0.575 42.572 34.949 3.731 11.649 8.996 0.000
38. 419 ZHOU-SPARKS-M 74 48.975 0.662 52.007 0.610 43.144 36.944 3.773 11.815 9.419 0.000
39. 457 chunk-TASSER 78 48.969 0.628 50.524 0.646 44.833 34.876 3.800 11.927 8.845 3326.593
40. 324 AOBA 75 48.624 0.648 48.935 0.614 41.614 34.917 3.772 11.588 9.055 0.000
41. 353 SAMUDRALA 77 48.483 0.630 50.607 0.630 44.909 36.239 3.798 11.826 8.987 0.000
42. 119 MULTICOM-REFINE 78 47.864 0.614 50.204 0.544 41.494 35.584 3.759 11.618 9.255 1622.988
43. 300 4_BODY_POTENTIALS 67 47.301 0.706 52.053 0.671 47.472 36.830 3.798 12.059 8.666 0.000
44. 002 MULTICOM-CLUSTER 78 46.903 0.601 50.594 0.574 41.770 35.636 3.762 11.779 9.277 1623.218
45. 452 Seok-server 78 45.887 0.588 50.226 0.547 42.187 35.556 3.757 11.608 9.024 3792.757
46. 453 HHpredA 78 45.546 0.584 48.684 0.689 43.058 35.160 3.784 11.366 8.946 3.116
47. 346 HHpredC 78 45.546 0.584 48.684 0.708 42.824 35.160 3.784 11.366 9.236 3.147
48. 449 HHpredB 78 45.546 0.584 48.684 0.689 43.058 35.160 3.784 11.366 9.236 3.407
49. 458 Bilab-solo 77 45.014 0.585 49.807 0.545 43.199 35.288 3.763 11.717 9.017 0.000
50. 215 MULTICOM-NOVEL 78 44.287 0.568 49.777 0.522 40.587 35.005 3.762 11.628 9.268 1623.539
51. 236 gws 78 43.443 0.557 48.762 0.487 39.526 34.746 3.797 10.903 9.241 4279.804
52. 395 Shell 78 43.325 0.555 48.572 0.557 42.094 32.993 3.868 11.950 8.632 0.000
53. 060 CNIO 45 42.775 0.951 44.159 0.992 35.645 29.960 3.776 9.318 6.198 0.000
54. 253 pro-sp3-TASSER 78 42.099 0.540 49.704 0.563 43.322 34.130 3.799 11.596 8.621 3269.739
55. 477 MidwayFoldingHuman 73 41.743 0.572 50.074 0.547 42.639 34.947 3.805 11.674 8.296 0.000
56. 174 Phyre2 78 41.487 0.532 49.447 0.602 42.778 34.664 3.801 11.771 8.787 1015.984
57. 382 Kurcinski-Kihara 77 39.816 0.517 47.939 0.493 39.635 32.764 3.834 11.569 8.378 0.000
58. 080 MULTICOM-CONSTRUCT 78 39.576 0.507 49.015 0.467 38.890 34.686 3.763 11.381 9.124 1623.912
59. 360 sbtJ 77 39.373 0.511 48.597 0.479 41.324 34.112 3.756 11.535 9.195 0.000
60. 423 Bilab 77 38.600 0.501 46.261 0.454 38.317 31.683 3.775 11.047 7.868 0.000
61. 063 Jiang_Assembly 78 38.123 0.489 47.828 0.450 37.758 33.121 3.776 10.847 8.631 1659.876
62. 166 ZHOU-SPARKS-X 78 38.057 0.488 48.810 0.461 39.620 34.418 3.758 11.190 8.841 125.808
63. 127 FAMSD 78 37.181 0.477 47.262 0.486 40.362 33.031 3.858 10.968 8.860 618.272
64. 061 MUSICS-2 63 36.752 0.583 50.060 0.579 41.209 35.396 3.797 11.696 9.403 0.000
65. 366 Jiang_THREADER 78 36.373 0.466 48.596 0.449 40.774 33.825 3.767 10.925 8.750 1968.021
66. 103 SAM-T08-server 73 36.104 0.495 46.779 0.499 38.552 33.221 3.876 10.337 7.864 1103.082
67. 484 FEIG 73 34.613 0.474 44.841 0.524 36.736 31.501 3.828 9.940 7.308 0.000
68. 424 Bates_BMM 71 34.023 0.479 43.080 0.518 35.194 29.626 3.793 10.149 7.145 0.000
69. 165 GSmetaserver 69 33.630 0.487 48.641 0.422 40.337 34.687 3.776 11.878 9.203 1141.696
70. 273 Pcomb 73 33.462 0.458 47.797 0.426 40.228 33.658 3.776 11.394 8.981 1669.712
71. 208 PconsD 78 32.698 0.419 46.058 0.373 38.156 32.093 3.798 10.972 7.981 2438.249
72. 481 MUFOLD-Server 78 32.342 0.415 45.683 0.415 35.868 32.383 3.771 10.180 8.065 3983.098
73. 035 CNIO-Firestar 55 31.371 0.570 52.496 0.616 47.283 36.906 3.769 12.472 9.775 0.000
74. 055 MUFOLD-MD 76 31.007 0.408 43.389 0.402 34.240 30.036 3.781 9.613 6.900 3288.664
75. 056 PconsM 74 29.811 0.403 46.910 0.404 39.879 33.101 3.758 10.951 8.766 1125.326
76. 307 chuo-fams 78 29.163 0.374 44.887 0.384 36.298 31.107 3.855 10.293 7.590 812.389
77. 102 Bilab-ENABLE 78 28.968 0.371 43.599 0.396 35.172 30.719 3.761 9.997 8.029 1097.617
78. 319 Pcons 70 28.334 0.405 48.719 0.422 41.068 34.507 3.809 11.873 9.664 130.944
79. 291 prdos2 76 28.138 0.370 44.877 0.447 36.499 31.201 3.773 10.179 7.628 3871.935
80. 199 MUSICS 58 28.117 0.485 46.626 0.489 37.486 32.825 3.795 10.905 8.540 0.000
81. 450 BHAGEERATH_SCFBIO 78 27.866 0.357 42.248 0.380 33.089 28.142 3.858 10.203 7.245 0.000
82. 142 CLEF-Server 78 27.432 0.352 44.965 0.348 36.775 31.299 3.761 10.487 8.376 923.235
83. 275 IntFOLD-TS 78 27.122 0.348 44.536 0.374 37.052 31.690 3.755 10.192 8.283 227.301
84. 435 MidwayFoldingServer 78 27.011 0.346 43.442 0.351 33.590 29.598 3.787 10.371 8.173 4428.669
85. 047 BioSerf 78 26.729 0.343 43.338 0.337 32.988 30.181 3.784 10.118 7.573 200.596
86. 302 FALCON-SWIFT 78 26.690 0.342 44.921 0.345 36.769 31.265 3.761 10.472 8.376 853.791
87. 218 3D-JIGSAW_V4-0 75 26.647 0.355 44.917 0.469 39.193 31.588 3.811 10.752 7.544 273.628
88. 476 FFAS03n 76 24.799 0.326 42.393 0.365 34.784 29.279 3.756 9.832 8.143 3.773
89. 213 circle 66 23.790 0.360 47.409 0.426 42.180 33.545 3.870 11.407 9.317 2909.875
90. 173 PconsR 73 23.134 0.317 45.167 0.302 37.727 31.178 3.795 10.847 8.063 2547.370
91. 149 LMU 67 23.022 0.344 44.862 0.335 35.684 31.550 3.773 9.523 7.576 0.000
92. 001 ProQ2 72 22.753 0.316 44.575 0.317 35.446 31.052 3.777 10.652 8.615 1668.674
93. 028 ProfileCRF 78 22.048 0.283 42.288 0.337 34.296 30.071 3.757 9.566 7.633 685.860
94. 409 MUSTER 78 21.977 0.282 42.323 0.285 32.482 29.358 3.758 9.702 7.890 42.056
95. 117 3D-JIGSAW_V4-5 71 21.780 0.307 43.904 0.331 37.158 30.650 3.829 10.614 7.882 387.039
96. 471 FFAS03 71 21.589 0.304 43.650 0.277 36.377 30.421 3.758 11.057 8.845 3.184
97. 214 Distill 78 20.183 0.259 42.716 0.288 32.597 29.083 3.805 9.506 6.495 124.743
98. 170 FOLDIT 34 20.150 0.593 50.790 0.581 40.913 34.933 3.799 9.673 6.771 0.000
99. 186 Distill_human 77 19.077 0.248 41.622 0.292 31.527 28.159 3.795 9.392 6.290 0.000
100. 316 Lovell_group 71 18.740 0.264 29.875 0.269 15.813 20.158 3.800 4.649 2.046 0.000
101. 171 FFAS03ss 71 18.597 0.262 42.984 0.307 35.415 30.028 3.756 10.635 8.404 3.693
102. 345 PRECORS 72 18.448 0.256 39.416 0.279 28.553 25.881 3.780 8.635 6.412 3301.795
103. 207 Atome2_CBS 69 18.415 0.267 42.119 0.315 32.728 29.158 3.756 10.194 7.659 38.458
104. 042 Handl-Lovell 72 18.031 0.250 28.721 0.299 13.857 19.665 3.800 4.243 1.794 0.000
105. 018 Wolfson-serv 76 17.437 0.229 39.350 0.272 30.920 27.768 3.799 9.004 7.184 36.551
106. 403 StruPPi 77 17.229 0.224 40.056 0.179 28.398 27.114 3.769 9.706 7.596 0.000
107. 461 jscslb 54 17.199 0.318 45.442 0.340 36.266 31.402 3.762 11.171 9.024 0.000
108. 447 SWIFT-Human 74 16.270 0.220 34.067 0.188 20.687 22.981 3.758 6.409 4.674 0.000
109. 420 FFAS03a 73 16.068 0.220 42.117 0.237 34.637 29.493 3.757 10.539 8.374 4.015
110. 220 CLEF 73 15.560 0.213 33.379 0.183 19.872 22.421 3.758 6.291 4.514 0.000
111. 129 MUSICS_server 76 15.536 0.204 34.576 0.215 24.988 22.983 3.793 6.970 5.332 4315.990
112. 391 SMEG-CCP 71 15.514 0.219 39.590 0.264 28.989 25.123 3.759 8.904 5.113 0.000
113. 304 Ma-OPUS-server 78 15.020 0.193 37.478 0.173 25.454 25.280 3.753 8.255 6.269 471.046
114. 245 PROTAGORAS 58 14.794 0.255 43.127 0.280 35.394 28.935 3.758 10.862 8.028 81.029
115. 436 panther 61 13.830 0.227 39.140 0.232 33.312 27.773 3.770 9.548 7.785 347.184
116. 026 LOOPP_Austin 63 13.322 0.211 44.401 0.227 37.219 31.553 3.759 11.064 9.029 148.166
117. 285 SAM-T02-server 60 13.028 0.217 42.997 0.298 35.675 31.601 3.869 9.722 8.223 284.951
118. 301 cpu_hsfang 66 12.801 0.194 40.414 0.258 34.486 29.463 3.838 9.657 8.070 0.000
119. 045 POEM 76 12.384 0.163 38.085 0.161 27.199 25.693 3.845 9.270 6.893 0.000
120. 083 FLOUDAS 48 12.309 0.256 43.402 0.226 30.983 29.091 3.781 8.104 4.304 0.000
121. 296 ProQ 61 11.886 0.195 43.369 0.308 37.603 30.716 3.771 10.954 8.336 1654.774
122. 314 LMUserver 66 10.269 0.156 37.023 0.161 25.477 25.595 3.762 8.254 6.695 4398.251
123. 396 FUGUE_KM 67 9.842 0.147 41.113 0.183 32.704 29.068 3.876 10.135 8.433 23.729
124. 244 SAM-T06-server 68 9.679 0.142 38.376 0.185 28.239 26.583 3.856 7.690 6.332 959.899
125. 075 RaptorX-FM 17 9.490 0.558 31.100 0.277 10.714 20.945 3.798 4.311 1.829 3601.972
126. 328 Pushchino 69 7.884 0.114 32.714 0.152 20.048 21.979 3.820 6.240 4.871 195.816
127. 228 YASARA 27 7.630 0.283 55.323 0.242 47.804 39.799 3.814 14.472 12.411 4352.628
128. 311 ALAdeGAP 74 7.490 0.101 34.979 0.104 22.890 23.705 3.764 8.397 7.193 0.000
129. 278 sessions 78 7.124 0.091 33.952 0.127 23.009 22.411 3.941 7.915 5.436 0.000
130. 009 Ben-Tal 21 7.001 0.333 56.715 0.377 50.204 41.118 3.803 15.013 10.376 0.000
131. 153 AuroraMBSI 46 6.804 0.148 34.099 0.097 19.543 23.087 3.794 5.779 2.967 0.000
132. 282 Taylor 31 6.457 0.208 32.423 0.207 19.654 21.671 3.761 6.442 4.823 0.000
133. 074 m4t_2009 17 6.187 0.364 53.844 0.327 46.707 39.994 3.759 15.159 14.253 151.772
134. 355 LenServer 66 5.782 0.088 24.542 0.117 8.201 16.335 3.800 2.716 0.753 3715.137
135. 029 Yuan-Chen-Kihara 74 5.478 0.074 30.743 0.078 18.941 20.938 3.778 6.417 5.136 0.000
136. 439 disco3 11 5.381 0.489 46.249 0.381 38.901 32.467 3.757 14.682 11.873 0.000
137. 248 MUSICS-2S 60 5.201 0.087 33.284 0.100 21.698 22.758 3.765 6.823 5.237 3734.639
138. 084 LenGroup 78 4.003 0.051 22.471 0.132 5.116 14.790 3.800 2.062 0.500 0.000
139. 350 RBO-PROTEUS 75 3.535 0.047 23.395 0.067 6.921 15.698 3.794 2.894 1.188 1024.603
140. 206 WAC_Labs 78 3.138 0.040 30.223 0.050 17.302 19.893 3.825 6.369 4.595 0.000
141. 257 STAT-PROTEUS 63 3.046 0.048 23.870 0.089 8.001 15.375 3.794 2.632 0.757 1271.326
142. 105 TUM_Bioinf_Praktikum 7 3.039 0.434 56.214 0.382 51.407 40.196 3.794 19.412 17.600 0.000
143. 347 GOBA_PL_07 19 2.861 0.151 42.349 0.196 35.014 29.485 3.864 9.806 7.689 0.000
144. 160 ppfld 7 2.364 0.338 35.633 0.037 5.707 23.143 3.843 2.119 0.114 0.000
145. 333 DELCLAB 72 2.299 0.032 24.625 0.053 11.911 16.163 3.834 3.978 2.360 0.000
146. 020 dokhlab 34 2.248 0.066 33.139 0.090 16.539 22.603 3.798 6.360 3.882 0.000
147. 200 MeilerLab 70 2.013 0.029 23.982 0.044 6.011 14.994 4.561 2.372 0.664 0.000
148. 358 GOBA_Wroc_PL 19 1.698 0.089 42.973 0.102 36.788 30.265 3.865 12.232 9.653 0.000
149. 189 3SP-TsaiLab 12 1.640 0.137 57.060 0.163 55.705 40.641 3.824 20.447 16.942 0.000
150. 182 Scheraga 44 1.511 0.034 22.721 0.044 3.865 13.463 3.777 2.547 0.743 0.000
151. 014 PLATO 52 1.422 0.027 18.873 0.049 3.217 12.050 3.764 1.724 0.340 865.676
152. 264 ConStruct 58 1.222 0.021 21.421 0.072 3.804 14.321 3.793 1.680 0.157 938.872
153. 184 SmartFold 3 1.160 0.387 66.399 0.427 66.967 48.672 3.763 25.713 23.333 0.000
154. 229 BHAGEERATH 78 0.904 0.012 19.533 0.017 2.576 11.780 3.857 1.309 0.086 3761.989
155. 044 ProteinShop 6 0.902 0.150 27.058 0.187 8.062 18.006 3.820 2.935 0.483 0.000
156. 289 Yang_kdd 66 0.878 0.013 20.987 0.058 7.415 12.981 3.915 3.556 2.042 1238.304
157. 373 Wolynes 41 0.593 0.014 25.675 0.060 6.677 16.463 3.800 2.055 0.602 0.000
158. 250 rehtnap 56 0.553 0.010 32.082 0.046 17.074 19.588 3.664 7.337 3.850 441.073
159. 152 dill_score 8 0.419 0.052 30.259 0.000 1.228 19.807 3.825 2.134 0.288 0.000
160. 154 JAMMING 25 0.286 0.011 28.722 0.023 9.458 15.814 3.750 11.054 7.608 0.000
161. 330 SSEFR 10 0.252 0.025 22.694 0.034 12.661 16.209 3.885 6.990 6.440 0.000
162. 261 Partha_BDU_India 1 0.041 0.041 57.692 0.007 55.240 35.315 3.840 19.331 12.800 0.000
163. 279 Mohamed_Ismael_Lab 19 0.000 0.000 16.392 0.033 4.375 10.599 3.875 4.081 3.005 0.000
164. 362 Fortmann_server 4 0.000 0.000 14.186 0.000 0.172 7.521 3.755 0.478 0.000 4372.201
165. 086 dill_beef_smoothed 5 0.000 0.000 24.854 0.000 1.316 13.350 3.822 0.935 0.240 0.000
166. 331 dill_sa_smoothed 5 0.000 0.000 23.535 0.000 0.878 14.081 3.822 1.167 0.480 0.000
167. 336 SUN@tsinghua 39 0.000 0.000 17.221 0.076 3.343 11.479 3.800 0.474 0.097 0.000
168. 039 dill_beef 6 0.000 0.000 25.664 0.000 4.745 15.312 3.827 1.550 0.617 0.000
169. 140 dill 5 0.000 0.000 28.660 0.000 6.870 18.072 3.868 1.881 0.300 0.000
170. 322 dill_remd 7 0.000 0.000 29.103 0.000 2.256 18.953 3.869 1.993 0.286 0.000
171. 433 dill_sa 5 0.000 0.000 22.325 0.000 0.656 13.160 3.822 1.060 0.380 0.000
172. 178 FKinitial 5 0.000 0.000 14.223 0.000 0.350 8.356 3.752 0.150 0.000 0.000
173. 444 schenk-torda-server 18 0.000 0.000 22.440 0.020 4.333 13.775 3.800 1.175 0.089 3009.341
174. 269 dill_score_smoothed 6 0.000 0.000 31.257 0.043 1.998 19.161 3.823 1.977 0.250 0.000
 
Protein Structure Prediction Center
Sponsored by the US National Library of Medicine (NIH/NLM)
Please address any questions or queries to:
© 2010, University of California, Davis