10th Community Wide Experiment on the
Critical Assessment of Techniques for Protein Structure Prediction
Menu
Group performance based on MODEL 1 analysis

DISCLAIMER. Summary scores in this page are based solely on the results of automatic evaluation of models and can not be considered as final CASP10 results. These scores are just a starting point in the official assessment, which takes into account other aspects of model quality. For a detailed assessment please refer to the assessors' papers (to be published in Proteins in 2013) or presentations.

  Model 1   Best model
    • All groups on 'all groups' targets
    • Server groups on 'all groups' + 'server only' targets
    • TBM easy (max gdt_ts >=50 )
    • TBM hard (max gdt_ts < 50 )
    • TBM/FM
    • FM
    • OTHER
# GR # GR name Domains Count SUM Z-score
(GDT_TS)		 AVG Z-score
(GDT_TS)		 AVG GDT_TS No. models
ranked 1		 No. models
in Top3		 No. models
in Top10		 No. models
GDT_TS>30		 No. models
GDT_TS>40		 No. models
GDT_TS>50		 No. models
GDT_TS>80		 AVG Z-Score
(GDT_HA)		 AVG Mammoth
(Z-Score)		 AVG Dali
(Z-Score)		 AVG response time, min
1. 237 zhang 71 71.293 1.004 49.046 3 8 31 55 44 34 9 0.972 12.895 9.732 N/A
2. 035 s Zhang-Server 71 63.544 0.895 47.825 2 5 21 53 44 35 6 0.894 12.347 9.407 2669.644
3. 350 Kloczkowski_Lab 71 61.772 0.870 46.157 5 12 25 52 38 31 6 0.847 11.926 8.946 N/A
4. 489 MULTICOM 71 59.969 0.845 45.966 4 6 15 49 39 30 7 0.813 11.847 9.220 N/A
5. 130 Pcomb 71 59.638 0.840 46.665 3 3 17 53 42 29 7 0.843 12.067 9.004 N/A
6. 267 Pcons 70 58.432 0.835 46.336 2 3 19 51 40 30 6 0.809 12.204 9.254 N/A
7. 114 s QUARK 71 58.076 0.818 47.101 1 6 16 54 42 32 7 0.802 12.040 9.131 2673.288
8. 388 ProQ2 71 57.813 0.814 43.943 3 4 18 51 36 24 5 0.785 11.176 8.075 N/A
9. 079 TASSER 71 57.283 0.807 47.248 2 6 21 52 39 35 9 0.857 11.892 9.130 N/A
10. 475 CNIO 71 56.550 0.796 47.049 3 4 16 52 42 33 6 0.787 12.269 9.351 N/A
11. 027 LEEcon 71 54.653 0.770 47.145 3 9 21 49 40 35 7 0.816 11.981 9.468 N/A
12. 197 Mufold 71 54.569 0.769 45.829 3 6 21 50 40 29 9 0.770 11.910 9.139 N/A
13. 294 chuo-repack 71 54.485 0.767 46.054 3 7 16 51 38 29 7 0.702 11.378 8.583 N/A
14. 477 BAKER 70 52.697 0.753 47.311 6 7 20 48 39 32 4 0.791 11.964 9.484 N/A
15. 490 Zhang_Refinement 71 52.200 0.735 46.235 3 5 14 48 42 32 7 0.705 11.841 9.076 N/A
16. 344 Jones-UCL 69 51.944 0.753 46.539 4 6 21 50 41 32 4 0.730 12.181 9.465 N/A
17. 315 keasar 67 51.575 0.770 44.819 4 5 11 50 36 26 3 0.725 11.986 8.657 N/A
18. 365 chuo-fams 71 50.863 0.716 45.043 2 4 11 50 38 27 6 0.698 11.409 8.734 N/A
19. 458 Sternberg 71 50.714 0.714 45.347 1 4 15 49 41 31 6 0.663 11.818 8.610 N/A
20. 428 PconsQ 70 50.116 0.716 45.225 2 3 12 49 38 28 6 0.668 12.069 8.990 N/A
21. 434 chuo-fams-consensus 71 48.151 0.678 45.043 1 4 9 52 38 29 6 0.627 11.628 8.615 N/A
22. 045 Zhang_Ab_Initio 71 47.171 0.664 45.523 0 5 12 49 39 30 6 0.645 11.159 8.400 N/A
23. 285 McGuffin 69 46.569 0.675 43.813 1 1 14 46 37 25 6 0.657 11.229 8.380 N/A
24. 301 LEE 71 44.307 0.624 45.226 5 9 16 44 39 31 8 0.676 11.286 9.007 N/A
25. 481 Chicken_George 71 44.117 0.621 44.663 1 2 13 49 37 26 9 0.627 11.197 8.768 N/A
26. 335 s TASSER-VMT 71 43.969 0.619 43.332 2 8 16 46 32 26 8 0.708 10.686 8.534 4134.613
27. 122 s RaptorX-ZY 71 43.945 0.619 44.639 0 3 10 48 40 28 5 0.703 10.964 8.980 4329.999
28. 486 s RaptorX 71 43.447 0.612 44.518 0 2 4 48 40 28 6 0.699 11.223 9.028 4234.031
29. 405 Mufold2 68 42.390 0.623 43.883 1 3 16 45 36 26 7 0.639 11.518 8.543 N/A
30. 026 ProQ2clust 71 41.936 0.591 43.227 0 2 8 45 33 25 8 0.607 11.102 8.618 N/A
31. 103 s PconsM 71 40.982 0.577 41.740 2 4 10 45 37 23 4 0.574 10.519 7.839 1498.627
32. 317 SHORTLE 63 40.875 0.649 46.325 0 2 10 44 36 27 4 0.677 11.655 8.965 N/A
33. 330 s BAKER-ROSETTASERVER 71 40.560 0.571 42.237 3 5 18 43 34 25 3 0.637 10.456 8.066 2978.985
34. 281 Ariadne 70 40.262 0.575 42.407 1 2 10 45 34 27 6 0.608 10.944 8.173 N/A
35. 108 s PMS 71 38.737 0.546 43.256 3 5 11 43 37 25 5 0.542 10.976 8.577 4431.755
36. 292 s Pcons-net 70 38.301 0.547 40.756 2 4 10 43 35 23 5 0.547 10.547 7.777 1550.339
37. 101 WeFold 65 37.906 0.583 42.226 1 6 9 39 31 24 7 0.580 10.645 7.751 N/A
38. 164 4_BODY_POTENTIALS 69 37.539 0.544 42.533 0 1 10 45 33 25 7 0.524 10.650 7.710 N/A
39. 430 s HHpredA 71 36.386 0.512 42.294 2 5 9 45 34 23 7 0.519 10.323 7.665 6.280
40. 223 s HHpredAQ 71 36.219 0.510 42.305 2 5 9 45 34 23 7 0.517 10.308 7.610 6.284
41. 370 s HHpred-thread 69 36.117 0.523 43.639 4 5 8 44 35 22 9 0.569 10.626 7.570 11.510
42. 493 LEEMO 71 35.846 0.505 42.708 0 2 7 42 37 26 5 0.486 10.402 8.227 N/A
43. 280 ProQ2clust2 71 35.689 0.503 41.495 1 3 9 43 31 24 7 0.481 10.603 8.289 N/A
44. 473 Seok 70 33.898 0.484 41.876 0 2 2 39 35 26 7 0.556 10.375 8.796 N/A
45. 298 MidwayFolding 61 33.322 0.546 43.181 0 3 8 42 33 25 3 0.630 11.026 8.857 N/A
46. 141 Bates_BMM 69 31.692 0.459 40.441 1 1 6 42 33 20 2 0.485 10.011 6.986 N/A
47. 178 Bilab 64 31.405 0.491 40.487 0 0 6 39 31 23 2 0.482 11.109 8.303 N/A
48. 125 s MULTICOM-REFINE 71 31.272 0.440 40.727 0 0 4 41 30 22 6 0.423 10.096 7.721 4.240
49. 488 s chunk-TASSER 71 30.917 0.435 41.156 0 1 8 41 32 24 5 0.473 9.890 7.976 2841.650
50. 424 s MULTICOM-NOVEL 71 30.283 0.427 41.182 0 2 5 41 32 24 6 0.400 10.133 7.903 13.787
51. 435 ossia 71 28.773 0.405 41.395 1 2 5 41 33 20 7 0.404 10.483 8.218 N/A
52. 081 s MULTICOM-CLUSTER 71 28.638 0.403 40.722 0 1 6 41 31 24 7 0.380 10.183 7.728 419.580
53. 479 Boniecki_LoCoGRef 50 28.093 0.562 42.631 0 1 5 34 24 16 4 0.499 10.467 7.610 N/A
54. 453 KnowMIN 71 27.600 0.389 38.969 0 1 7 41 29 19 2 0.413 9.580 7.127 N/A
55. 286 s Mufold-MD 71 27.419 0.386 39.254 0 0 5 41 33 24 1 0.415 9.435 7.046 4354.772
56. 333 s MUFOLD-Server 72 27.380 0.380 39.152 1 2 6 39 34 24 3 0.368 9.518 7.514 4442.297
57. 222 s MULTICOM-CONSTRUCT 71 27.147 0.382 39.942 1 1 5 41 31 23 4 0.368 9.936 7.655 39.992
58. 373 Kim_Kihara 71 26.367 0.371 40.370 0 0 3 46 37 20 1 0.251 10.839 6.610 N/A
59. 411 s FALCON-TOPO 71 25.638 0.361 38.337 1 3 6 40 31 18 1 0.363 9.486 7.054 271.141
60. 456 s FALCON-TOPO-X 71 25.333 0.357 37.444 2 3 7 41 31 16 2 0.380 9.317 6.589 271.095
61. 172 Zhang-IRU 55 25.222 0.459 35.511 1 1 8 29 17 13 2 0.519 7.171 4.455 N/A
62. 348 s Phyre2_A 71 23.962 0.337 39.328 0 2 2 42 33 22 4 0.343 9.491 7.083 2701.493
63. 113 s SAM-T08-server 59 23.809 0.404 41.685 0 0 5 38 25 19 2 0.475 10.722 7.681 871.578
64. 148 s MUFold_CRF 69 23.714 0.344 36.285 1 4 4 34 26 17 1 0.344 9.073 6.652 4351.773
65. 437 sumalab 69 23.457 0.340 41.819 0 0 4 44 34 22 3 0.366 10.318 7.935 N/A
66. 413 s ZHOU-SPARKS-X 71 23.088 0.325 38.104 0 2 3 40 32 19 3 0.274 9.452 6.699 27.419
67. 261 s Seok-server 71 22.223 0.313 39.481 0 1 3 36 32 21 7 0.391 9.111 7.115 836.893
68. 077 FLOUDAS 50 21.823 0.436 37.355 1 1 6 28 20 12 2 0.424 7.965 4.810 N/A
69. 029 shisen 47 20.859 0.444 44.798 0 1 3 33 25 18 1 0.407 10.987 8.151 N/A
70. 124 s PconsD 70 18.784 0.268 37.333 0 0 3 35 28 19 4 0.280 9.272 6.761 1343.317
71. 302 s 3D-JIGSAW_V5-0 65 18.362 0.282 38.185 0 0 1 38 27 18 1 0.346 9.856 6.785 446.293
72. 112 s samcha-server 67 18.057 0.270 33.173 1 1 5 28 26 15 3 0.288 8.128 6.084 787.931
73. 072 s Distill 71 16.882 0.238 37.931 1 1 2 41 29 19 3 0.241 9.292 6.311 83.123
74. 300 PAX 67 16.552 0.247 38.053 0 0 0 40 29 20 1 0.245 9.640 7.645 N/A
75. 043 sessions 70 15.956 0.228 36.112 2 2 2 34 28 17 2 0.224 8.853 6.417 N/A
76. 163 s hGen3D 71 15.590 0.220 35.618 0 0 1 35 28 18 3 0.180 8.870 6.534 47.051
77. 273 s IntFOLD2 71 15.187 0.214 35.956 0 0 2 36 31 18 4 0.180 9.078 6.751 424.376
78. 343 s NewSerf 71 14.043 0.198 35.540 0 0 0 34 27 18 2 0.222 8.674 6.359 70.537
79. 277 s Bilab-ENABLE 71 13.527 0.191 33.785 0 0 1 32 24 18 1 0.186 8.093 6.086 1394.201
80. 175 s FRESS_server 71 12.596 0.177 35.144 0 0 2 36 27 17 1 0.134 8.800 5.993 4471.442
81. 221 s Atome2_CBS 58 12.348 0.213 37.008 1 1 3 31 24 15 2 0.200 9.284 7.076 68.702
82. 198 s chuo-fams-server 71 12.257 0.173 37.220 0 0 0 38 30 16 3 0.137 9.242 7.120 4225.887
83. 375 s FFAS03c 70 11.968 0.171 34.369 1 1 2 29 25 16 2 0.203 8.084 6.510 14.192
84. 115 s slbio 69 11.966 0.173 35.268 1 3 3 31 28 18 1 0.189 8.101 5.806 4440.532
85. 195 s RBO-MBS 71 11.684 0.165 21.846 0 2 4 10 6 3 0 0.177 2.520 1.232 3494.808
86. 087 s Distill_roll 71 11.384 0.160 33.251 0 2 2 27 19 16 1 0.099 7.813 5.007 75.156
87. 358 s RaptorX-Roll 21 11.112 0.529 24.742 1 2 4 6 2 1 0 0.513 2.914 0.857 214.272
88. 419 s Jiang_Server 71 10.946 0.154 30.305 1 1 2 27 17 12 0 0.128 7.055 5.128 719.115
89. 381 s SAM-T06-server 58 10.894 0.188 33.367 1 1 1 24 18 12 1 0.173 7.428 5.817 384.356
90. 121 s STRINGS 56 10.535 0.188 35.668 0 1 2 26 20 14 3 0.141 9.156 6.025 3714.760
91. 463 s Jiang_Fold 71 10.380 0.146 30.015 1 1 2 25 19 12 1 0.176 7.070 5.324 949.254
92. 498 s IntFOLD 71 9.930 0.140 32.682 0 0 0 29 21 17 2 0.127 7.772 6.092 408.543
93. 238 s chuo-repack-server 71 9.604 0.135 34.333 0 0 1 33 23 14 3 0.107 8.452 6.631 4403.891
94. 024 POEMhome 38 9.504 0.250 43.484 0 0 0 24 21 16 2 0.242 9.470 6.900 N/A
95. 492 s RBO-i-MBS 71 9.473 0.133 21.640 0 0 2 12 6 1 0 0.151 2.567 0.992 3494.858
96. 282 Jiang_Human 71 9.243 0.130 32.439 0 0 0 28 23 14 1 0.142 7.683 5.803 N/A
97. 204 s FFAS03mt 59 9.039 0.153 35.803 0 1 3 28 25 16 3 0.194 9.104 7.519 15.180
98. 494 s GSmetaserver 35 8.978 0.257 38.310 0 0 1 18 15 10 2 0.271 9.278 7.394 837.597
99. 258 s Jiang_Threader 71 8.343 0.118 27.713 1 1 1 19 14 11 0 0.118 5.893 4.711 41.081
100. 356 s sysimm 31 8.148 0.263 40.080 0 0 2 20 15 9 1 0.314 9.692 5.994 616.354
101. 476 s AOBA-server 69 8.128 0.118 32.155 0 1 1 28 22 16 1 0.157 6.986 4.788 4089.170
102. 247 s BhageerathH 71 8.088 0.114 29.831 0 0 0 24 16 11 2 0.112 6.822 4.479 3831.570
103. 275 s FFAS03hj 58 7.969 0.137 36.744 0 0 1 31 24 16 4 0.144 9.547 7.128 16.121
104. 439 s MATRIX 60 7.747 0.129 33.679 0 0 0 24 20 16 2 0.114 8.147 6.018 3554.397
105. 471 chuo-binding-sites 69 7.695 0.112 33.004 0 0 1 31 21 13 2 0.103 8.081 5.945 N/A
106. 259 ALAdeGAP 67 7.350 0.110 26.401 0 0 1 15 12 10 3 0.137 6.023 5.031 N/A
107. 040 s FFAS03 58 7.331 0.126 35.879 0 0 1 29 26 16 1 0.143 9.260 7.428 11.336
108. 464 s UGACSBL 54 7.042 0.130 37.287 0 0 0 25 19 15 3 0.119 10.303 7.731 1827.299
109. 457 s PROTAGORAS 46 6.755 0.147 38.874 0 0 0 26 20 14 2 0.137 10.761 8.450 577.303
110. 107 s RBO-i-MBS-BB 71 6.330 0.089 21.045 0 0 1 12 7 0 0 0.106 2.488 0.883 3493.005
111. 068 FOLDIT 11 6.166 0.561 55.574 0 1 1 9 8 5 3 0.534 6.482 3.991 N/A
112. 201 TsaiLab 66 5.761 0.087 29.184 0 0 0 18 15 11 2 0.121 6.192 4.982 N/A
113. 190 s RBO-MBS-BB 71 5.553 0.078 21.585 0 0 1 14 6 3 0 0.088 2.551 0.990 3492.546
114. 254 CaspIta 68 4.630 0.068 26.437 0 0 0 18 11 9 2 0.094 6.580 5.501 N/A
115. 251 laufercenter_meta 8 4.622 0.578 63.681 0 0 2 7 7 6 3 0.675 6.803 4.625 N/A
116. 028 s YASARA 26 4.614 0.177 46.046 0 1 1 16 13 11 4 0.195 12.309 10.362 4336.358
117. 474 WAC_LABS 71 4.417 0.062 27.701 0 0 1 24 15 9 1 0.087 6.021 4.683 N/A
118. 111 SIAT1068 71 4.282 0.060 27.183 0 0 1 16 13 10 1 0.053 6.369 5.483 N/A
119. 149 wfFUIK 11 4.257 0.387 48.505 0 0 0 8 7 5 1 0.458 6.190 3.691 N/A
120. 117 MBBS 70 3.844 0.055 23.304 0 0 1 13 8 6 2 0.053 4.575 3.933 N/A
121. 165 Void_Crushers 11 3.790 0.345 52.591 0 0 0 8 7 5 2 0.285 6.833 3.764 N/A
122. 260 wfFUGT 10 3.630 0.363 52.706 0 0 1 9 7 5 2 0.442 6.009 3.720 N/A
123. 085 Anthropic_Dreams 10 3.363 0.336 45.364 0 0 0 8 7 4 0 0.125 6.995 4.090 N/A
124. 341 Contenders 10 2.724 0.272 52.587 0 0 0 8 7 4 1 0.218 7.017 3.480 N/A
125. 116 s HOMER 47 2.340 0.050 28.455 0 0 1 17 12 8 0 0.040 7.915 6.679 124.008
126. 088 s panther 45 2.049 0.046 28.051 0 0 0 15 10 9 0 0.058 6.322 4.831 1692.902
127. 420 Handl 34 2.025 0.060 27.805 0 0 0 7 5 4 0 0.069 3.576 1.403 N/A
128. 215 ppfld 9 1.849 0.205 54.208 0 0 0 8 6 4 2 0.331 10.274 6.500 N/A
129. 448 KIAS-Gdansk 14 1.837 0.131 25.945 0 0 0 4 2 1 0 0.062 2.121 0.936 N/A
130. 376 Litonghua 70 1.677 0.024 19.016 0 0 0 7 5 4 1 0.053 1.911 1.571 N/A
131. 131 BioNanopore 12 1.455 0.121 43.020 0 0 0 7 7 5 0 0.107 15.006 12.825 N/A
132. 444 Lenregular 5 1.385 0.277 18.037 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0.313 1.917 0.360 N/A
133. 152 Cornell-Gdansk 30 1.175 0.039 22.386 0 0 0 7 4 0 0 0.004 2.142 0.547 N/A
134. 290 Wallner 2 1.068 0.534 52.569 0 0 0 1 1 1 1 1.044 15.941 15.250 N/A
135. 441 WeFoldMix 6 1.068 0.178 44.991 0 0 0 4 3 2 0 0.165 5.707 3.433 N/A
136. 466 Taylor 13 0.975 0.075 19.994 0 0 0 3 0 0 0 0.071 2.395 2.015 N/A
137. 030 TAUbioinfounit 3 0.935 0.312 46.320 0 0 0 3 2 1 0 0.273 22.234 14.333 N/A
138. 462 s confuzz3d 18 0.821 0.046 22.084 0 0 0 3 2 1 0 0.007 0.926 0.133 4088.771
139. 287 wfCPUNK 16 0.795 0.050 23.905 0 0 0 4 2 0 0 0.008 1.997 0.862 N/A
140. 265 MicroSumaLab 31 0.755 0.024 28.043 0 0 0 10 7 5 0 0.019 7.383 5.148 N/A
141. 246 MeilerLab 27 0.715 0.026 24.365 0 0 0 5 4 0 0 0.045 2.233 0.878 N/A
142. 179 s Lenserver 16 0.595 0.037 26.388 0 0 0 3 2 1 0 0.055 2.341 0.619 4230.739
143. 098 s confuzzGS 19 0.490 0.026 26.422 0 0 0 5 4 1 0 0.000 3.238 1.200 4090.248
144. 311 Laufer 9 0.470 0.052 47.655 0 0 0 6 4 4 1 0.036 6.471 3.189 N/A
145. 482 biouv 36 0.253 0.007 15.760 0 0 0 1 1 1 0 0.074 0.579 0.058 N/A
146. 010 TSlab-refine 1 0.134 0.134 71.552 0 0 0 1 1 1 0 0.014 26.716 21.900 N/A
147. 433 Sun_Tsinghua 49 0.071 0.001 15.921 0 0 0 4 1 0 0 0.010 0.672 0.188 N/A
148. 048 s Bhageerath_abinitio 2 0.052 0.026 49.363 0 0 0 2 1 1 0 0.000 0.611 0.000 4081.695
149. 155 Graham 10 0.000 0.000 7.710 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.000 0.400 0.010 N/A
150. 051 thyzju 8 0.000 0.000 15.804 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0.000 0.461 0.000 N/A
Protein Structure Prediction Center
Sponsored by the US National Institute of General Medical Sciences (NIH/NIGMS)
Please address any questions or queries to:
© 2007-2013, University of California, Davis